logo.


What you do may just
go down in history

Commentary

By Robert A. Leopold

Commentary on the past and future of Buddhism in America.



A hot topic these days at Sangha meetings has been “American Buddhism.” Our recently-crafted “Mission Statement” focuses on American Buddhism. The Founding Principles of the Buddhist Temple of Chicago (BTC) mention American Buddhism, and Rev. Gyomay Kubose's teachings have been frequently characterized as American Buddhism.

So what is American Buddhism?

I, for one, don't know how to answer this question. Is it the Buddhism of BTC? Is it the Buddhism of the Midwest Buddhist Temple (MBT)? Or how about the Buddhism of the many Zen centers in the Chicago area? You could easily make a case that all of these are “American Buddhism,” since their styles of practice are so different from those of lay people in Asia.

Maybe I don't have an answer to “what is American Buddhism” because I just don't know enough. I probably haven't read enough books about Buddhism, or engaged in enough Buddhist discussion groups, or spent nearly enough time in zazen.

While I acknowledge my limited Buddhist background, I would like to propose that the question “what is American Buddhism?” is, to a large degree, unanswerable. Yet within this “un-answerable-ness” lies considerable food for thought.

Rev. Kubose





Bodhi Leaf. Beginning of Buddhism in Japan
In his landmark work, The History of Japanese Buddhism, author Masaharu Anesaki suggests the date of 538 (AD) as the “beginning” of Buddhism in Japan. At that time, Buddhism was presented to the court of Yamato by a delegation sent by the Prince of Kudara (a principality in southern Korea) as a sign of homage and friendship. Over the ensuing centuries, Buddhism evolved in Japan, and many different denominations rose and fell.

One of the Buddhist denominations possibly most familiar to the readers of this issue of Sangha Notes is Jodo Shinshu (“True Pure Land”). This distinctly Japanese denomination was brought to flower by Shinran Shonin (1173-1263), a disciple of Honen. Furthermore, the beginning of the thirteenth century in Japan was a time when at least two other “major” denominations also began to take root; denominations which today still have many adherents. One is Nichiren (not to be confused with the Soka Gakkai—known in the US as NSA). The other is Japanese Zen.

From the time of Buddhism's introduction in Japan to the time of Shinran Shonin required 700 years of evolution. Then, you must add another 800 years of refinement to arrive at the Jodo Shin Shu of today, as practiced on the eve of the twenty-first century.





Buddhism first comes to America
The history of Buddhism in America is, obviously, dramatically shorter. Some people point to 1893 as the date that Buddhism “came to America”—the date of the first World Parliament of Religions, in Chicago. Since then, in the short span of almost exactly 100 years, we Americans have been fortunate to benefit from an influx of Buddhist teachings and heritages from all over Asia.

Over the past 100 years, Buddhism in this country has evolved and changed, influenced by the potpourri of cultures and sub-cultures which can be found coexisting only in the US. As we approach the twenty-first century, Buddhism has even become an important way of life for many American people with no Asian heritage whatsoever. So, maybe it's fair to analogize and say that Buddhism in America is in a similar embryonic state as it might have been in Japan in the year 642.

I wonder if the practitioners of Buddhism in 7th century Japan concerned themselves with whether or not they were practicing “Japanese Buddhism.” My guess is that they just practiced, and were less concerned with the name, or label, they applied to their practice.

flower2.




susuki.

Why worry about the label?
One of the points brought up during Sangha's recent efforts to develop a Mission Statement was just this: “Should we be so concerned with the label American Buddhism and what this label means?“ I thought this was a pretty good question. However, a very logical—and readily accepted—viewpoint was that we need to let ourselves, and whoever else is interested, know what we do and what we stand for. True. Very true. So that's what we're attempting to do.

But in doing so, let us not fall into the trap of forgetting that this label is merely a label, and not the actual reality of our practice, or philosophy, or our way of life. As Alan Watts stated in The Way of Zen, “To serve their purpose, names and terms must of necessity be fixed and definite like all other units of measurement. But their use is—up to a point—so satisfactory that man is always in danger of confusing his measures with the world so measured... to the degree that he identifies himself and his life with these rigid and hollow frames of definition, he condemns himself to perpetual frustration... ... 'name-and-form' is the mind's attempt to grasp the fluid forms of nature in its mesh of fixed classes.“

What could be more fluid than the evolution of Buddhism in America today?





Evolution of Buddhism in America
As Buddhists, we are very fortunate to be living in this place and time... at the dawn of American Buddhism, in a city which could be characterized as the birthplace of American Buddhism. It's an exciting time, especially with the evolution of Buddhism in America being sped up through the rapid dissemination of information via television, computer-produced documents (such as this newsletter), and the literally instantaneous, literally world-wide communication of the Internet.

Our practice is changing. We are changing it. It is changing us. No one can predict the direction it will take.

Perhaps, in the year 2397, there will be the widely-accepted denomination of (American) Buddhism known as Bright Dawn. Or, conversely, as speculated in the 11/96 issue of the BTC Bulletin, perhaps our American Buddhist leaders, for whom many of us have the utmost in respect, may simply turn out to be “...transient player(s)in the ‘venerable master’ role.” Only our distant heirs will know the answers.

One thing we do know, however, is that how it turns out is up to us. All of us.

You can have an influence in creating the future. The Heartland Sangha is a vigorous and lively participant in whatever tiny role we may possibly be playing in shaping the future of American Buddhism. Our meetings have passion, energy, humor, arguments, love, and great food. Buddhism, with whatever label or denomination you might care to apply, is alive and kicking within our group.

We encourage anyone and everyone who's interested to become involved. Who knows, what you do may just go down in history.

Editor's Note, this article is reprinted from the
Sangha Notes newsletter.

To subscribe to the free email newsletter please email us.

You can also influence the future by joining or starting a sangha in your area. We have some sample Buddhist services on our site to give you an idea of what we do. Feel free to contact us if you have any questions on "sangha building."





We also have an article on A Brief History of Buddhist Sects. This article explores the events that mark the time of the Buddha Sangha's split into two groups--Mahayana and Hinayana (known as Theravada).


Kubuse Dharma Legacy.

| Welcome to Heartland Sangha | Daily Dharma Practice
| Sample Buddhist Services | Nourishment Offering |
| Engaged Buddhism | American Buddhism |
| Buddhist Quotes | Photo Gallery |
| Current Articles | Past Articles |
| Buddhist Book Reviews |
| Schedule of Events | Resources & Links |


©2008, Heartland Sangha
All Rights Reserved